Which recommendations are usually required
This section explains which recommendations a private school application usually includes. Most schools ask for two or three: the current English teacher, the current mathematics teacher, and a school recommendation form completed by the principal or a school counselor. Some schools add an optional supplementary recommendation from a teacher or coach in an area outside the classroom.
| Recommender | What the school learns | Required |
|---|---|---|
| Current English teacher | Performance in reading, writing and class discussion | Usually required |
| Current mathematics teacher | Mathematical thinking, problem-solving approach and study habits | Usually required |
| Principal or counselor (school recommendation form) | The student’s overall record at school, character and relationships with others | Usually required |
| Supplementary recommendation | Commitment outside the classroom, from a teacher or coach in music, athletics or community service | Optional |
Source: application materials requirements on school admissions pages (examples in this page’s sources), checked for the ISEEPrep school directory on 2026-10-03.
Each school’s admissions page sets its own requirements. Schools differ mainly in three ways: for lower-grade applicants, some schools ask for a form from only one teacher; some schools use a shared recommendation form; and some divide the supplementary recommendation into specialties such as the arts or athletics. When building the school list, record the number of recommendations and the recommenders each school requires.
How to choose recommenders
The recommendation is the only part of the application written by a third party and unseen by the family. What the family can do is choose the right recommenders, ask early and prepare well. Three principles help in choosing.
- Principle: How well the teacher knows the student matters more than title
- Explanation: Specific details from a teacher who sees the student every day carry more weight than a letter from a school leader who has met the student a few times.
- Principle: Prefer current teachers
- Explanation: Schools want to know the student as he or she is now. If a current teacher has only just started, ask the school whether a teacher from the previous year is acceptable.
- Principle: The strongest subject is not always the best choice
- Explanation: A teacher who watched the student move from struggling to improving can often write a more persuasive recommendation.
Each school’s admissions page sets the specific requirements for recommenders.
On current teachers, some schools set strict rules: the English and mathematics recommendations must come from current teachers, and an earlier teacher may only add a personal recommendation. Under such a rule, a teacher from the previous year who truly knows the student can write a separate personal recommendation, rather than replacing the current teacher’s recommendation.
The value of a supplementary recommendation is that it shows a side of the student the school cannot see in the other materials, such as long-term commitment to an instrument, a sport or community service. A supplementary recommendation that repeats the subject recommendations adds little, and when a school marks it optional, there is no need to add one just for the count.
When to ask
This section explains the timing of recommendation requests. Teachers write recommendations for many students in the fall and winter, and the earlier the request, the more time a teacher has to write specific content. Most schools set application deadlines between December and mid-February, with the first half of January the busiest period.
Source: ISEEPrep’s school-by-school check of the admissions pages of the 245 US private schools in its school directory, checked 2026-10-22. School-by-school dates are in the school directory.
The request is best made politely, in person or by email, six to eight weeks before the earliest deadline on the list, which usually means late October to mid-November. Three points in time follow, ending at the earliest deadline.
- Six to eight weeks before the deadline: make the request. Explain how many schools the student is applying to and each deadline, and ask which submission method the teacher prefers. Once the teacher agrees, hand over the prepared materials at one time; the contents are in the next section.
- Around Thanksgiving and winter break: the easiest time to miss. Teachers are busiest then, and items are easiest to overlook. Point out the school with the earliest deadline separately; for schools with deadlines in the first half of January, recommendations are best submitted before winter break begins.
- One to two weeks before the deadline: check the submission status once. Check in the application system whether each recommendation has been submitted; if one has not, send the teacher one polite reminder.
Note: plan backward from the earliest deadline. Deadlines differ across the list. A plan built on the latest deadline can leave the earliest school without a recommendation when its deadline arrives.
What to give teachers
This section lists the materials to give a teacher with a recommendation request. A short, clear packet noticeably lightens the teacher’s load and helps the recommendation be specific.
- A one-page student profile: interests, activities and the reasons for applying to private school.
- One or two moments from this class that stood out: recalled and written down by the student, for the teacher’s reference.
- The school list: each school’s name, deadline and submission link or method.
- A short thank-you note: and after the admissions season, whatever the outcome, telling the teacher the result and thanking him or her again.
These materials help the teacher recall specific details; they do not draft the content for the teacher. The profile and the moments should be written as facts, without suggested phrases of praise for the teacher to use. The school list works best sorted by deadline, earliest first, matching the timing in the previous section.
Submission and follow-up
This section explains what the family still needs to do once recommendations are requested. At most schools, recommenders submit directly through the school’s online application system and are asked to keep the recommendation confidential. A confidential recommendation is more credible in the school’s eyes, so parents should not ask to read it and should not take part in writing it.
Most application systems show whether a recommendation has been submitted, and parents can follow up on that basis. Respect the teacher’s time: one reminder is enough, focused on confirming that the submission method is working. ISEE scores do not go through teachers. After scores are released, the parent adds receiving schools in the registration account, and adding schools carries no extra fee; the contents of the score report are in score reports. When checking materials, confirm separately that recommendations, the school transcript and ISEE scores have each arrived.
Source: E3n, ISEE score reports (admission.org), checked 2026-08-24.
After the admissions season, whatever the result, families should tell the teachers who wrote recommendations how it turned out and thank them. The teachers gave time to the student, and this step respects that effort.
Families applying from outside the US
This section explains how students attending school outside the US arrange recommendations. These students usually ask the English teacher and the mathematics teacher at their current school, and the school recommendation form is completed by the principal or a school leader who knows the student.
Language requirements vary by school: some schools explicitly allow recommenders to write in their own language, and others require English or a translation. When a target school requires English, the English teacher can write the letter, or a translation can be attached; a translation should be faithful to the original, adding and removing nothing. Teachers at schools outside the US are often unfamiliar with US application systems, so the family can put each school’s submission steps and deadline on one page for the teacher and suggest submitting a few days early to allow for the time difference.
The target school’s admissions page sets the language requirement and submission method. Families abroad also have extra preparation for English proficiency, interview formats and guardianship; see applying from abroad.
Frequently asked questions
How many recommendation letters does a private school application need?
Usually two or three: the current English teacher, the current mathematics teacher, and a school recommendation form completed by the principal or a school counselor. Some schools also accept a supplementary recommendation from a teacher or coach outside the classroom. Each school sets its own number.
Can parents read the recommendation letters?
Usually not. At most schools, teachers submit recommendations directly to the school and are asked to keep them confidential. A confidential recommendation is more credible in the school's eyes, so parents should not ask to read it and should not take part in writing it.
Can a student attending school outside the US ask teachers at that school for recommendations?
Yes. A student attending school abroad usually asks the English teacher and the mathematics teacher at the current school. When a school requires English, the English teacher can write the letter or a translation can be attached; some schools also allow recommenders to write in their own language. The target school sets the language requirement and the submission method.
What if a teacher forgets to submit a recommendation?
Send one polite reminder one to two weeks before the deadline and confirm that the submission method is working. Most application systems show whether a recommendation has been submitted, which lets parents follow up while respecting the teacher's time.
Can a student ask a teacher from the previous school year?
It depends on the school. Some schools require the English and mathematics recommendations to come from current teachers, and an earlier teacher can write a separate personal recommendation as a supplement. When a current teacher has only just started with the student, the family can explain the situation to the school and ask whether a teacher from the previous year is acceptable.
Is an optional supplementary recommendation worth submitting?
It is not required. A supplementary recommendation suits a side of the student that the subject recommendations do not show, such as long-term commitment to the arts, athletics or community service. If its content would repeat the subject recommendations, or no recommender truly knows the student in that area, it can be skipped.
Sources4 sources · checked 2026-11-13
Last reviewed 2026-11-13 · Next review 2027-03-31 · Reviewed by ISEEPrep teaching team
Book a free consultation
Share the entry grade and target schools; within one business day an advisor replies with a written plan for the testing seasons and the order of application materials.
Book a free consultation →